The misconception that "you should endure and continue even if the pain is strong"
Pendulum exercises are a typical form of exercise used in rehabilitation to improve shoulder joint contracture and increase range of motion, but the misconception that "continuing the exercises even if it hurts a little will help you heal faster" is a medically extremely dangerous misconception. For those recovering from a fracture or surgery, pain is not just discomfort, but an important signal that indicates the progression of tissue damage and inflammation. The longer you endure and continue the exercises, the more you hinder recovery and even run the risk of prolonging functional impairment.
In fact, orthopedic and rehabilitation doctors generally advise patients to "stop if pain increases." This is because forcing a joint to move when inflammation is present in the synovial fluid, fascia, and ligaments within the joint can cause the inflammation to spread, potentially worsening secondary symptoms such as heat and swelling in the affected area and nighttime pain. This is something that should be particularly noted in the early stages of rehabilitation for shoulder periarthritis and proximal humerus fractures, and there are many cases where patients mistakenly believe that "enduring pain = effective" based on their own judgment.
The following table provides a brief summary of the criteria for pain:
| State Example
|
Continuation or not
|
Solution
|
| Dull discomfort after exercise
|
Conditionally allowed
|
Apply ice and rest to see how it goes.
|
| Throbbing pain during exercise
|
Needs to be cancelled
|
Stop exercising and consult a doctor
|
| Severe pain and swelling the next day
|
Completely cancelled
|
Signs of recurrence or worsening. See a doctor immediately.
|
| If you reduce the swing range, it will be painless.
|
Possible depending on the situation
|
Reduce the number of times as much as possible
|
There have also been many clinical reports of cases where treatment was prolonged as a result of continuing to exercise while suffering from pain. In one orthopedic facility, an elderly patient who continued exercising despite the pain on his own accord developed myositis and required hospitalization for treatment. This is not an uncommon case, and it is a risk that lurks nearby, especially for the elderly and those who perform self-rehabilitation.
The appropriate time to start pendulum exercises and the appropriate intensity settings vary greatly depending on the disease, surgical history, age, etc. For example, in the case of a proximal humerus fracture, strenuous exercise is contraindicated until 3 to 4 weeks, which is the estimated time for bone union, and enduring pain while exercising before that time may cause re-fracture or false joint.
In conclusion, the idea that you should endure pain and continue with pendulum exercise is fundamentally wrong, and it is necessary to flexibly adjust the exercise to suit the patient's physical condition. In particular, for those who are unfamiliar with rehabilitation or the elderly, the shortest route to recovery is to proceed safely and effectively under the guidance of a physical therapist or orthopedic specialist.
The dangerous method of "If you want to recover quickly, swing quickly"
Many people mistakenly believe that "swinging faster will increase the range of motion" when performing pendulum exercises. However, such high-speed exercises are strictly prohibited in rehabilitation settings. The essence of pendulum exercise is to "improve the range of motion of joints through natural vibrations without exerting force," and intentional high-speed exercises deviate from the purpose of the exercise and cause unnecessary stress to the affected area.
Particular attention should be paid to patients and elderly people who perform pendulum exercises at home on their own. They have difficulty in understanding the sensation of relaxing and may mistakenly believe that "swinging harder is more effective," and may end up contracting the muscles around the scapula and biceps more than necessary. In this state, the effect of the original "non-weight-bearing exercise" is lost, and instead the shear force on the tendons and joints increases, which can lead to re-injury and inflammation.
Thus, the principle of pendulum movement is "slowly, effortlessly, and naturally." By increasing the speed, you may temporarily get a "sense of movement," but this is merely an illusion and does not lead to fundamental improvements such as recovery of range of motion or circulation of synovial fluid in the joints.
Furthermore, the act of shaking too quickly is often caused by psychological "impatience," and is a typical pattern in which the patient's desire to "recover as quickly as possible" ends up having the opposite effect. To counter this sense of impatience, medical professionals need to clearly explain that "the recovery process is different for each person," and that "the most reliable path is to build up strength little by little within the limits of what does not cause pain."
In addition, in rehabilitation after a proximal humerus or clavicle fracture, there are stages of exercise according to the progress of bone union, and sudden vibration exercise not only impedes that progress, but also carries the risk of re-fracture. One of the reasons why patients tend to repeat fast movements on their own is due to a lack of explanation of exercise guidelines by medical professionals.
Therefore, rather than pursuing speed, the key to maximizing the effectiveness of pendulum exercise is to focus on quality, such as "how to relax" and "how to regulate your breathing." Rehabilitation instruction that values precision and a sense of security, rather than speed, is what leads to the patient's early return to society.